Guest Column

Democrats Do A Better Job

By Herbert H. Hash, Jr.

Since becoming eligible to vote I have regularly voted Democratic, even though on occasion, when I have felt that the best candidate was a Republican, I have voted Republican. I have not been an active member of either party, other than to vote, until recently. I have now become so disturbed by the rhetoric and actions of the Bush administration that I have become more active in the Democratic Party. In addition, I have publicly protested the Iraq war on the streets of Boone and in Asheville, and I have written a number of letters to the editors of several newspapers expressing my views with regard to the overall policies and practices of this administration.

I have been particularly distressed with regard to the concept of "pre-emptive war" and the keeping of "enemy combatants" in Guantanamo Bay and other places for long periods of time without benefit of legal counsel and without charges being brought. And I have been very disturbed at the torture of prisoners in our care at Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo and other places, done with disregard for the rules of the Geneva Convention of 1949 and apparently with the approval of the administration. As Senator John McCain has so rightly said, "It is not about them. It is about us."

There are other concerns which have caused me to become more active in politics. I believe this administration has used the phrase “War on Terror” to manipulate Congress and the American people as a whole into a state of fear in order to get laws passed which are not in keeping with Democratic ideals and the best traditions of America. The manipulation of intelligence to justify the Iraq War is one example. The push to use torture as an intelligence-gathering technique is another. A disregard for the Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty of 1970 is another. Pulling out of the ABM Treaty of 2001 is another. The rush to pass the Patriot Act, some parts of which are unpatriotic (like the investigation of American citizens without proper warrants or authority) is another.

As a former combat engineer officer who proudly wore the American uniform, I am offended that on numerous occasions those of us who question the policies and activities of this administration are called "unpatriotic"! President Teddy Roosevelt, a Republican, said that one of the most important things an American citizen can do is to question his government.

The Bush administration has also, with its head in the sand, neglected the research of the majority of the world’s scientists -- research which shows that global warming is a serious problem and that the United States is a major contributor to the pollution which causes global warming. The rejection of the Kyoto Accords is illustrative. Also there is ample evidence that the administration has ordered the "doctoring" of scientific evidence to make the information come more into line with its ideology and policies. I usually vote Democratic on environmental issues because I believe Democrats do a better job of facing up to the truths of good science and taking action that benefits the American people as a whole.

The unilateralism of this administration, confirmed by the appointment of John Bolton as our ambassador to the United Nations, is imperialistic and dangerous. The "Bring ’em on!" attitude of President Bush has caused our country to lose the support of a number of nations we once considered our strong allies and in many cases rules out any kind of intelligent diplomacy. There can be a tough-minded approach to diplomacy without being imperialistic. I believe that, in general, Democrats do a better job when it comes to diplomacy.

America is not a monarchy. Neither is it a theocracy. The First Amendment to our Constitution, in my opinion, prohibits the establishment of any official state church; at the same time, it forbids the passing of any laws which might interfere with religious freedom. So ours is a democracy in which there is at least an implied separation of church and state. This does not mean a divorce of religious beliefs from public service. It does mean, however, that political leaders should not use government to impose their beliefs on others. In recent years a number of Christians, often called "the Religious Right," have developed a lot of political power through such groups as the Moral Majority and the Christian Coalition and have used this political power in such ways as to impose their beliefs on other.

Government interference in the Terri Schiavo case is illustrative; Republicans have so strongly identified with the Religious Right that they have become the political arm of a religious movement. (Former Senator John Danforth, a Republican and an ordained minister, said as much in a New York Times article in 2005.) Church and state should be able to cooperate with one another without "getting into bed" with each other. From a genuine Christian perspective, if the church gets too cozy with the government, who speaks truth to power? I believe Democrats do a better job of following Jesus’ admonition, "Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and to God the things that are God’s" (Matthew 22:21).

As a basis for becoming more active in politics, I have talked about matters of war and peace, civil rights, care for the environment, unilateralism, and church and state. I could go on to discuss at length gun control (the Assault Weapons Ban was allowed to lapse in 2004) and health care (more than 40 million Americans still uninsured), but one must be selective in articles such as this.

I wrap up by saying that all my concerns come out of the background of my Christian faith. I am familiar with the teachings of both the Old and New Testaments and can cite biblical texts to support most of my positions with regard to most of the concerns I have mentioned. I believe Christians are called to be peacemakers and to respect every person as someone for whom Christ died. I believe Christians are called to be good stewards of the God-given environment we have. I believe Christians are called to be good citizens with high moral standards. I believe Christians are called to be citizens of the Kingdom of God and of the kingdoms of this world -- with priority to be given to the Kingdom of God (and we should never confuse America, nor any political party, with the Kingdom of God). If believers put the Kingdom of God first, especially as outlined by Jesus (Luke 4:16-20 and Matthew 22:34-40), the outcome will be what is best for America and the Kingdom of God. Whatever party, whatever faith, we must all work for the common good of America.

Herb Hash is a retired Baptist minister and former chaplain at the Watauga Jail Chapel. He teaches theology and ethics at Appalachian State University and lives and votes in Brushy Fork.