Guest Column

Are the American People Suckers?

by Marsha Walpole

I’m a small business owner and a middle-class American. When I started this column for this newspaper, it was about how the middle class in America has been losing ground over the past 20 years. I’ve read lots of evidence that this is true, from Paul Krugman’s book on the topic, The Great Divergence, Timothy Noah’s ten-part series in Slate entitled “Why We Can’t Ignore Growing Income Inequalities,” and recent CNN stories on income stagnation.

But what I came to realize is that I don’t need to tell anyone who is a member of the working class that he or she isn’t making any more money than they did five or 10 years ago, and that their dollars don’t stretch as far as they used to.

During the real estate boom, we could ignore the fact that we didn’t get raises, not even cost-of-living increases, because we could use our homes as an ATM and withdraw a little cash whenever we ran short, like when we needed a new car or our parents or children were sick. Some of us even used that money for less responsible spending, like a vacation now and then.

But that all ended when banks stopped lending to anyone but each other, and now even those of us who still have jobs or small businesses can’t get loans, even from banks and credit unions we have done business with for many years.

So I decided that I would write about what our recently elected members of Congress, state representatives, and County Commission are doing about this problem of income inequality. After all, they campaigned on bringing jobs back to us and jump-starting the economy.

What I found was that the amount of legislation they have passed in the nearly five months they have been in office to address this problem would make a mighty short column.

Our state legislators have been wasting time on a voter ID bill and trying to nullify federal health-care legislation, when they should have been working on ways to hold the line on de-funding education. Now more than ever we need to prepare our children for 21st century jobs that are going overseas.

Our new representatives in Raleigh have been pressuring Governor Perdue to roll back incentives for companies coming to North Carolina, incentives which brought Google, Apple, Facebook, and WiPro data centers here in the past three years. They probably would have taken away collective bargaining too, like the legislators in Wisconsin, except that North Carolinians already gave up their right to that in 1959.

The new Republican majority in the U.S. House hasn’t done any better. Even though House Speaker John Boehner said on national television (Fox News, 1/30/2011), “Election day showed that the American people said we should focus on jobs,” the Republican agenda has been anything but. We have rehashed old arguments about what marriage should be, who should have health care, and the de-funding of National Public Radio instead of figuring out how to keep the economy rolling.

The new Republican majority has decried the stimulus package (which many of them voted for) as government waste, but they haven’t given us a clue as to what they are going to do now that the stimulus is over. They claim to be deficit hawks but are continuing to ignore the elephant in the middle of the budget called defense spending, which is a third more than Social Security and three times as much as Medicaid. All of this while ignoring the problem I started out to write about: that over the past 30 years, income has grown nearly 300 percent for the top 1 percent but only 25 percent for middle-income Americans. And they decided to give that 1 percent of the richest Americans a tax cut.

We Americans are ever optimistic. We believe that someday our ships will come in, and we’ll be as rich, glamorous, and successful as the celebrities we see on TV. But for the last 30 years or so, the deck has been increasingly stacked against us. We elected a new bunch of dealers, but it turns out the deck is full of jokers.

As the old saying goes, “If, after the first 20 minutes, you don't know who the sucker at the table is, it's you.”

Marsha Walpole runs a small business with her husband in Sugar Grove.